Blog / Brokers

ECN vs Market Maker Brokers: What the Difference Means for You

ECN, STP and market maker brokers route orders differently. Learn how it affects spreads, execution and conflicts of interest.

Market maker

A market maker takes the other side of your trade (a dealing desk). Spreads are usually fixed or wider and there are no commissions. The broker profits when clients lose, which is a conflict of interest that regulation tries to manage.

STP and ECN

STP brokers pass orders to liquidity providers. ECN brokers connect you to a pool where prices come from several providers, usually with tight spreads and a separate commission. Neither is automatically honest or dishonest; execution quality still depends on the firm.

Which is better for you

Scalpers and high-volume traders usually prefer ECN-style accounts for lower spreads. Small accounts trading rarely can be fine on standard accounts. Compare total cost (spread plus commission) on the pairs you actually trade.

How to judge execution

Test slippage and requotes on a small live account during news. Read independent reviews, check the regulator, and make sure negative balance protection applies where you live.

Example: comparing two accounts

Account A: spread 1.2 pips, no commission, so the cost is 1.2 pips. Account B: spread 0.2 pips plus a $7 round-turn commission per lot (about 0.7 pips). The cost of B is about 0.9 pips, cheaper by 0.3 pips.

If you trade 20 lots a month, B saves about $60. For a trader with 1 lot a month it saves $3, so the better choice depends on volume.

Account types are marketing names

Brokers use names such as "Raw", "Pro" or "Zero" for account types, and the underlying model can differ between them. Read the execution policy and the fee table rather than trusting the label. If a broker does not disclose how orders are routed, assume you trade against them and judge their cost and conduct on that basis.

Key takeaways

  • Market makers trade against you.
  • ECN means tight spread plus commission.
  • Compare total cost.
  • Test execution in volatile moments.

Related

Educational content, not financial advice.