The5ers vs TradeDay
Numbers read from each firm's own page (2026-10-28 and 2026-10-26). For each size we take every firm's cheapest plan and compare only what both list.
Direct answer
At $50,000, TradeDay has the lower evaluation fee ($249 for The5ers's High Stakes 2-Step ("NEW" tab, shown by default) vs $59 for TradeDay's Intraday evaluation (sale price, with the list price)). TradeDay wins on fee ($59 vs $249) and takes 2 of 3 metrics we can compare. This compares only the numbers both firms list, as of 2026-10-28.
Side by side by account size
$25,000 account
| Metric | The5ers (High Stakes 2-Step ("NEW" tab, shown by default)) | TradeDay (Intraday evaluation (sale price, with the list price)) |
|---|---|---|
| Fee | $176 | $45 |
| Profit target | 10% / 5% | $1,500 |
| Max loss | 10% | $1,000 trailing intraday |
| Daily loss limit | 5% | not listed |
| Profit split | 80%-100% | not listed |
$50,000 account
| Metric | The5ers (High Stakes 2-Step ("NEW" tab, shown by default)) | TradeDay (Intraday evaluation (sale price, with the list price)) |
|---|---|---|
| Fee | $249 | $59 |
| Profit target | 10% / 5% | $3,000 |
| Max loss | 8% | $2,000 trailing intraday |
| Daily loss limit | 4% | not listed |
| Profit split | 80%-100% | not listed |
$100,000 account
| Metric | The5ers (High Stakes 2-Step ("NEW" tab, shown by default)) | TradeDay (Intraday evaluation (sale price, with the list price)) |
|---|---|---|
| Fee | $405 | $108 |
| Profit target | 10% / 5% | $6,000 |
| Max loss | 8% | $3,000 trailing intraday |
| Daily loss limit | 4% | not listed |
| Profit split | 80%-100% | not listed |
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper, The5ers or TradeDay?
At $50,000, TradeDay has the lower evaluation fee ($249 for The5ers's High Stakes 2-Step ("NEW" tab, shown by default) vs $59 for TradeDay's Intraday evaluation (sale price, with the list price)). TradeDay wins on fee ($59 vs $249) and takes 2 of 3 metrics we can compare. This compares only the numbers both firms list, as of 2026-10-28.
The5ers vs TradeDay: which has the easier profit target?
At $50,000, The5ers's cheapest plan shows a profit target of 10% / 5% and TradeDay's shows $3,000. A lower target is easier, but compare the loss limits too.
Is The5ers or TradeDay more trusted?
ScaleEdge does not rank trust. Public Trustpilot ratings: The5ers 4.7 (40,434 reviews), TradeDay 4.6 (1,452 reviews). Ratings say nothing about rules or payouts on their own.
More
- The5ers: all account types and fees
- TradeDay: all account types and fees
- Change size or goal in the interactive comparison
- Fee calculator
This compares fees and limits only. It does not measure payout reliability, rule fairness, support or country eligibility. We may earn a commission if you sign up through our links. Educational content, not financial advice.